Case study – Perspective

Perspective

This out of court resolution course by RISE, Perspective, is designed to reduce the impact and frequency of hate crime, overall, reducing reoffending. It consists of a 1:1 remote session to engage and motivate offenders, followed by three groupwork sessions in person, run weekly.

Background

The service user was referred into our 4-session Intervention ‘Perspective’ following an incident at a protest. This involved s.5 public order offences at an anti-immigration demonstration. With another man, the service user appears to be affiliated to the EDL and BNP and shout their support for Tommy Robinson intermittently.

Risk assessment

During our first session, which is 1:1 and delivered online, the service user presented as open to the course whilst also being honest about his views on immigration in the UK.

He challenged some of what the police had referenced regarding the incident claiming he “hated Tommy Robinson” and did not align to far right politics. He was simply concerned about some harmful incidents that had taken place in his community perpetrated by an asylum seeker living in a local hotel which had left him feeling “worried and anxious.” He claimed his primary motivation was his concern for the safety of women in his community.

He did admit that he wrongly pushed past the police barricade, reporting that the demo escalated when “the anti-far turned up” and alleged that individuals in the hotel were “taunting” them which “rallied everyone up”.

The service user had mental health difficulties and his emotional state the day of his offence consequently impacted how he behaved.

Intervention

The service user took part in 3 further sessions, all delivered online and in a group with 5 other white individuals of mixed genders.

The first group session focuses on Hate Crime; what constitutes one and explores why we react the way we do in certain situations and how this could be linked to our beliefs. Overall, he contributed the most to conversations, seemingly comfortable in the space which therefore encouraged others to do so which was positive to see.

The next session looks at managing emotions, with an emphasis on anger, exploring triggers and coping strategies. He was very open, often the first person in the group to contribute answers. He volunteered straight away to discuss his incident whilst on the “rage gauge” exercise, describing himself as “raging” at the time of his offence, he reflected “I’m not really proud of it,” indicating he felt some remorse during this exercise. He was invited to explore what triggers were occurring at the time, and which emotional states he moved through before, during and after the demo.  During this segment another group member kept interrupting, attempting to collude with the service user’s behaviour and expressed quite a bit of anger towards any alternative perspectives so as to steer the conversation back into political waters. However, the practitioner was able to guide it back to the ‘rage gauge’ and the reflective quality of the exercise for the service user. But this again highlighted to the practitioner the undercurrent of political hostility that was present in the group and how this was creating problems with overall accountability.

In the final session, the group looks at alternative world views, unconscious bias and empathy. This involves participants choosing descriptors for their own identity and sharing them with one another to explore how others might perceive us based on how we look. During this exercise he stated “you can’t really judge a book by its cover” but went on to admit that we do anyway. This was useful framing for the next segment which explains stereotypes and unconscious bias, inviting participants to reflect on their own.

The session then moves onto more current affairs, inviting the group to participate in a “True or False” quick fire quiz looking specifically at asylum seeker facts and statistics. The exercise is designed to reveal where someone might be holding unsubstantiated opinions that are based on propaganda messaging. During this exercise the service user frequently got answers wrong, demonstrating a pattern of thinking that suggested he saw immigrants as a bigger issue; that that there were far more of them in the country and costing more money etc, than was factually accurate.

Immediately after this exercise a video was played that depicts a diverse group of people connecting over similarities rather than focusing on their differences and Mr H commented “I quite like that.”

Challenges

The service user himself did not present with challenges per se, however as mentioned above, one of the key challenges was the group dynamic which included a lack of peer challenge, this in combination with the nature of his offence meant that the group often colluded around a single perspective, subsequently reinforcing their beliefs. Exercises such as “True or False” in relation to immigration statistics were useful in challenging their shared perspective when a peer was not able to.

Much of this challenge was also overcome by the practitioner’s use of motivational interviewing techniques throughout; such as using open questions which invited the group to consider other viewpoints to their own.

Outcomes

He was one of the most engaged group members, often contributing first and supported others to contribute to.  He was confident in expressing his opinions, often those which featured his stance on immigrants, however it was clear during the exercises he was able to remain engaged with the material even when his perspective was being in-directly challenged; eg during the “True or False” and unconscious bias segments. Ultimately this in-direct challenge appeared to open him up to other ways of viewing the situation and his own bias.