A Domestic Abuse Policy Is Only as Strong as the Culture Around It

Most organisations can point to a policy explaining what should happen when an employee raises a concern about domestic abuse, but having a policy is not the same as having a workplace where people feel able to use it.

When we talk about organisational culture, we are describing the collective values, assumptions and everyday behaviours that shape how people experience work. Yet I think organisations can sometimes look for culture in the wrong places. It is easy to point to values statements and policies, but the true enacted culture is in the everyday decisions and responses when something difficult or uncomfortable happens.

When domestic abuse is involved, formal procedures are only part of the picture. They may tell an employee where to report a concern, but workplace culture can also influence what people notice and how they interpret and respond to concerning behaviour. Employees also learn from how the organisation responds in practice, particularly when someone challenges behaviour or raises a concern. This is why workplace responses to domestic abuse cannot stop at supporting individual employees but need to consider the wider structural and cultural conditions around them (Branicki et al., 2023).

This gap between what an organisation says should happen and what people actually experience in practice is what interests me in my PhD research: how organisational culture influences whether concerns about domestic abuse are recognised and managed effectively.

When culture becomes a label

The way we talk about organisations is worth examining. We readily describe workplaces as having a “good”,  “bad” or even “toxic” culture. These labels can draw attention to genuine problems, but they can also make culture sound like a fixed characteristic, as though everyone within an organisation experiences it in the same way. In reality, culture develops through what happens day to day and is a living system of behaviours and interactions. Different teams can establish their own norms, and these can shift as leadership and ways of working change.

This is why simply labelling an organisation as having a “bad culture” can be  limiting. The label may identify that something is wrong, but it tells us relatively little about what is actually producing that culture or what needs to change. It is more useful to look underneath the label and understand the everyday dynamics that shape what people come to accept and how they respond when problems arise.

When loyalty makes speaking up harder

I find policing a useful example because concerns about organisational culture have become particularly prominent and “police culture” is often discussed as though it were a single fixed thing, usually in negative terms. Looking underneath that label reveals more specific cultural dynamics. Trust and solidarity, for example, are important in police work, but a strength can become a weakness when loyalty makes a fellow officer’s behaviour more difficult to challenge.

The term “blue wall of silence” has been used to describe reluctance within policing to report wrongdoing by fellow officers (Anderson, Farmer & Tyson, 2025; Pidel, 2022). Hierarchy makes this even harder, as challenging someone more senior may feel professionally risky, particularly when officers know they may have to continue working alongside that person or their colleagues in the future.

Domestic abuse adds another layer to this. In 2024, the Centre for Women’s Justice (CWJ) reported that 45% of those who had provided detailed accounts of police-perpetrated domestic abuse were themselves current or former police officers or civilian police employees. For some victim-survivors, reporting abuse therefore means reporting into the same system that employs the person causing harm. That can make concerns about confidentiality, safety, professional relationships and career consequences difficult to separate from the decision to disclose. The important question is therefore not simply whether a reporting mechanism exists, but whether employees trust what will happen when they use it.

Culture can change

Just as organisational culture evolves over time through everyday behaviours and interactions, it can also be intentionally reshaped.

Policing itself also provides an example of deliberate attempts to do this. In 2025, the College of Policing and National Police Chiefs’ Council launched a National Policing Culture and Inclusion Strategy for 2025-2030, explicitly recognising the need to address cultural problems identified through recent reviews and rebuild trust both with the public and within the police workforce. The strategy places particular responsibility on leaders, with chief officers expected to support workforce development and oversee progress within their force. The Code of Ethics was also revised in 2024, alongside strengthened vetting standards.

These developments do not mean that the concerns raised by victim-survivors and research have disappeared, but they do show that organisations can take active steps to change the conditions that sustain them.

Rebuilding psychological safety

For me, one useful way of understanding how leaders can influence culture is through psychological safety. Rather than asking whether an organisation has a “good” or “bad” culture, it gives us something more specific to look at: do people trust that they can raise something difficult without being disadvantaged for doing so?

Psychological safety refers to the shared belief that it is safe to take interpersonal risks at work, such as questioning something or raising a concern, without fear of humiliation or unfair consequences (Edmondson, 1999). It exists at a group level and is built through everyday workplace interactions.

This does not mean creating a workplace where people are always comfortable or agree with one another. The importance of leadership is reflected in Edmondson and Bransby’s (2023) review of 185 psychological safety studies, which identified leadership as one of the dominant themes. One interesting finding was that leaders who openly shared criticism and feedback they had previously received helped normalise vulnerability, making similar openness more likely within their teams (Coutifaris & Grant, 2022).  For leaders, the task is therefore not to remove discomfort, but to make space for candid conversations while keeping the team cohesive and focused on its shared purpose.

That openness can change what an organisation sees. Early research on psychological safety produced a slightly counterintuitive finding: better-performing hospital teams appeared to report more errors, but closer examination suggested that they were simply more willing to acknowledge when things had gone wrong (Edmondson, 1999). A higher number of reported concerns may therefore reflect greater visibility rather than a worsening culture. In the context of domestic abuse, this could mean that more concerns coming to light reflect greater openness, not necessarily more harm. Direct research applying psychological safety to workplace responses to domestic abuse is still limited, and this is one area I hope to explore through my PhD.

Trust in these conditions is ultimately built through experience: people notice how leaders respond when concerns are raised and what happens to those who speak up. Over time, those experiences shape whether employees genuinely feel able to question behaviour or raise a concern.

Moving from bystander to upstander

Employees also shape culture through what they challenge or ignore, and how they respond when somebody raises a concern. A healthier culture makes it easier to recognise warning signs early and challenge harmful behaviour before it escalates.

This is where the distinction between being a bystander and an upstander becomes useful. Being an upstander does not mean investigating an allegation or putting yourself at risk, but recognising concerning behaviour and knowing how to respond appropriately.

This matters because culture is reinforced through everyday behaviour. When concerning behaviour is repeatedly ignored, it can become easier to normalise. When people feel able to challenge it early, they can interrupt the pattern and help set a different standard for what is acceptable. In the context of domestic abuse, this may include recognising patterns of intimidating or controlling behaviour rather than dismissing them as purely private matters.

Turning commitments into everyday practice

These ideas are already reflected in some of RISE Mutual’s practical work. Its People & Workplace Culture training is an evidence-informed course that explores the everyday behaviours and interpersonal dynamics that influence workplace culture, including psychological safety and the role of bystanders and upstanders.

Leaders have an important part to play in this too. Leveraging its expertise in sustained behaviour change, RISE offers bespoke development programmes that focus on building the confidence and capability of leaders and managers across sectors to strengthen how they lead teams through uncertainty and change, helping them create the conditions for psychological safety.

RISE’s work with policing provides a more specific example of what early cultural intervention can look like in practice. Promoting Respect in Action (PRiA) is an early-intervention programme for people who have demonstrated inappropriate sexual behaviour or failed to respond appropriately when witnessing it in others. Rather than waiting for harmful behaviours to become further embedded, the programme focuses on recognising them earlier and developing greater personal responsibility for the culture people help create.

What culture change requires

I do not think the answer is simply another policy. Policies matter, but their effectiveness depends on the culture surrounding them. The harder task is making sure that culture supports people to recognise concerns and respond appropriately when they arise.

For me, this is where my PhD and RISE’s practical work come together. My research is interested in the cultural mechanisms that shape whether domestic abuse becomes visible within organisations and how it is then understood and managed.

References

Anderson, B., Farmer, C., & Tyson, D. (2025). Police-perpetrated domestic and family violence: a scoping review of Australian and international scholarship. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy, 14(4), 45-64.

Branicki, L., Kalfa, S., Pullen, A., & Brammer, S. (2023). Corporate Responses to Intimate Partner Violence: Journal of business ethics, 187(4), 657-677.

Centre for Women’s Justice. (2024) Has anything really changed since the 2020 super-complaint? POLICE PERPETRATED DOMESTIC ABUSE. Retrieved August 27, 2026, from https://static1.squarespace.com/static/69ce2e0f6fcae1199cca3cec/t/6a6236d4b5a95a18747b93f0/1784821463017/CWJ%2B-%2BPPDA%2BReport.pdf

Coutifaris, C. G., & Grant, A. M. (2022). Taking your team behind the curtain: The effects of leader feedback-sharing and feedback-seeking on team psychological safety. Organization science, 33(4), 1574-1598.

Edmondson, A. (1999). Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams. Administrative science quarterly, 44(2), 350-383.

Edmondson, A. C., & Bransby, D. P. (2023). Psychological safety comes of age: Observed themes in an established literature. Annual review of organizational psychology and organizational behavior, 10(1), 55-78.

Pidel, J. (2022). Protecting victims of police-perpetrated domestic violence. Government law review, 15(2).