I am pretty sure that if you asked a mixed gendered group of human services’ professionals if they were anti-racists there would be consensus in the room.  Ask the same group ‘are you a feminist?’ and your room is likely to be divided.  This was my experience during a recent training event when I posed the question via an anonymous online poll.  Just 30 out of a possible 44 responses were a resounding yes and yet when presented with the statement, ‘men and women should have equal status and rights in society’ everyone present agreed.   The definition of feminism according to UN Women is ‘a movement to achieve gender equality and women’s empowerment.’  So why the disconnect?

The poll results mirror national attitude surveys.  A survey of 6,600 UK residents in 2025 showed that an even lower percentage (35%) of respondents identified themselves as feminists although a rather more reassuring figure of 83% favoured equality between the sexes.   And if you think that attitudes are more progressive amongst Gen Z respondents, the pro-feminist vote is between 40-50%, with roughly 30% of young men identifying in this way.

Somehow women’s indifference to an historical movement which helped criminalise domestic abuse, got us the vote and equal pay legislation (even if this only really relates  to jobs men like doing too) feels more disheartening than men’s aversion to the label.   Is it because they think it’s an outdated movement and that gender equality is in the bag now?   Apparently not.  In 2024, 68% of young women surveyed thought that ‘women have it harder than men these days’ and a whopping 90% said it would be the same case in 20 years’ time.   How sad is that?

From a feminist angle, of course women’s rejection of the label is down to the patriarchy who are always finding ways of putting us off radical action.  The anti-suffrage brigade portrayed campaigners either as bitter spinsters or, if married, fearsome matriarchs, forcing their emasculated husbands into aprons.   Now social media sites have legitimised a new Messiah for misogyny who exhorts men to put ‘entitled’, ungrateful ‘females’ in their place and assert their dominance.   As women, we are socialised to think anger is unbecoming and that we should prioritise our looks.  ‘Taught from their infancy that beauty is woman’s sceptre, the mind shapes itself to the body and roaming round its gilt cage, only seeks to adorn its prison’ said Mary Wollstonecraft in 1792.   In last week’s Guardian a 15-year-old girl writes of how often she sees posts made by women result in men pitching in to rate her attractiveness with the worst possible outcome being a rating of ‘Sub-5.’   One post from a rape victim, she said, resulted in males accusing her of lying and telling her to kill herself because she was so ugly she was ‘unrapeable.’

‘When nearly every comments section on a video of a girl my age is filled with disgusting and objectifying comments about her body from boys, it causes me to feel deeply uncomfortable in my own body…. Endless emphasis on beauty as worth and all kinds of videos criticising specific features, some of which I possess, have made me start to loathe my own face.’

It’s hard to summon up the energy or find the time to agitate when you’re compelled to spend hours contouring your beautiful young skin in the hope of being rated a 7+.  It’s easy to start thinking that the vile online posts represent the views of the majority of the opposite sex and to see protest or resistance as a pointless gesture.   And this of course plays into the hands of that small silo of males who are producing this content.

Curious to find out more about young men’s take on the subject, I raised the issue with a couple of my 20 year old daughter’s friends.   They said it wouldn’t cross their minds to call themselves feminists, one because they don’t see it as their territory and two, because they thought girls would take the piss if they did.  One said that girls want their boyfriends to be manly, pay for things and be a good shoulder to cry on.  They seemed equate being a male feminist with being more ‘feminine’ rather than with being an upstander or ally.   They also struggled to think of examples of female oppression in twenty first century Britain, taking the view that things were ‘more or less equal now’ although they were aware that wasn’t the case elsewhere in the world.  As a parting shot, one of them said that girls sometimes want it ‘both ways’ and need to ‘make up their minds.’  Clearly, they didn’t see what was in it for them when it comes to feminism but at the same time felt they were being nudged, possibly against their will, back into what Paul Kivel named the ‘Man Box’ and to be stoic protectors.

In Tony Porter’s 2010 landmark Ted Talk ‘A Call to Men’ he gives vivid examples of how a narrow and rigid script for manhood has played out in his family.  The most memorable for me was his account of a car journey following his brother’s funeral. He describes how his father suppresses his grief until his wife and daughters get out at a service station and then bursts into uncontrollable tears.   Porter said that he knew well that his father didn’t want to cry in front of him either but better that than the women see him break down.

‘And this is a man,’ he exclaims ‘who 10 minutes ago had just put his teenage son in the ground.’

The Man Box is bad for everyone, argues Porter and he goes on to illustrate other ways it plays out between fathers and sons, objectifies women and disconnects men from their emotions.

‘My liberation as a man,’ he winds up, ‘is tied to your liberation as a woman.’

With a number of studies highlighting a strong correlation between adherence to Man Box messaging and serious mental health issues (46% of men ‘in the box’ in one UK study) it would appear he is right.

So as we celebrate another International Women’s Day, my big wish would be for a wave of rage of tsunami proportions from women in the next year because I don’t want young girls to hate, starve and mutilate themselves because social media won’t regulate a minority of misogynists and because powerful men are almost never held to account for their abuse.  I would like to see men taking the street with banners in support of their partners, daughters and friends.   We have ‘Mothers Against Violence,’ so why not ‘Fathers against Rape?’  But maybe as women, there’s also value in us looking at our own subtle behaviours and the way we align ourselves to our own ‘box’ not only by playing out a prescribed gender role but also, perhaps, by expecting men to shoulder/pay/suppress too much.  As for whether we need to call ourselves feminists, well if it’s a concept that doesn’t appeal to the new generation, then let’s start re-branding.